Should Libraries Focus on Building Digital Collections Over Print Books?
Introduction>>
Libraries offer endless stories and knowledge, both on shelves and online. As technology changes how people read, a key question arises: should libraries invest more in eBooks, audiobooks, and digital databases or continue expanding their print book collections for readers who love turning real pages?
Constructive Debater 1 Loren
Libraries should prioritize digital collections because they reach more readers and expand access. With apps like Libby or NLB Mobile, people can borrow eBooks, audiobooks, and even newspapers anytime, anywhere. Digital resources help students study remotely and let multiple users read the same title at once. Some libraries even lend Wi-Fi hotspots, giving families without internet a way to connect and learn. Digitized archives also protect fragile originals while allowing students to explore real historical documents safely. Investing in digital ensures libraries serve everyone, everywhere.
Constructive Debater 2 Olivia
Relying too much on digital collections can create serious gaps. Many teens still prefer print, and browsing real shelves sparks discovery in ways apps can’t. Finland’s Helsinki Central Library Oodi features a “Book Heaven” floor with over 100,000 titles, showing how space and print inspire daily reading. Tokyo’s Tama Library also keeps a busy teen section with steady demand for physical books, while Seoul’s public reading spaces remain popular despite digital growth. Print is reliable ? no broken devices, expired licenses, or lost access ? just lasting books for everyone.
Rebuttal Debater 1 Loren
While physical books have charm, prioritizing print limits access and flexibility. Digital collections let libraries serve people who can’t easily visit in person, such as those in rural areas or with disabilities. They also reduce storage and maintenance costs, allowing libraries to invest more in programs and services. Digital tools can still encourage discovery through recommendations, previews, and online book clubs. By expanding digital resources, libraries ensure that learning and reading remain open to everyone, not just those near the shelves.
Rebuttal Debater 2 Olivia
Digital access sounds convenient, but it depends on stable internet and devices that many families still lack. Screen fatigue can also discourage deep reading and reduce focus, especially for students. Unlike eBooks that vanish when licenses expire, print copies stay available for years without extra fees. Libraries also serve as community spaces, where browsing shelves, sharing books, and attending story times build real connections. Prioritizing print keeps libraries welcoming, tangible, and dependable places for readers of all ages.
Judge’s Comments
Both sides presented clear, well-supported arguments on how libraries should shape their future collections. What do you think? Should libraries focus on building digital collections over print books?
May For The Junior Times junior/1763605211/1613368104
1. Why does Olivia argue print books remain more reliable?
2. Why does Loren say digital collections reach more readers?
3. Where does Olivia mention libraries that still thrive with print?
4. What benefits does Loren give for choosing digital over print?
1. Do you prefer reading print books or digital books?
2. Have you ever borrowed an eBook or audiobook from a library?
3. Do you enjoy browsing real shelves when choosing books?
4. Would you visit a library more often if it had more digital options?
Introduction>>
Rebuttal Debater 1 Loren 
