Copy or Create? The Dilemma of Using AI To Make Art
Introduction>> AI technology is rapidly transforming creative work. Some believe it’s acceptable to use automated tools to produce art quickly, even if it closely resembles existing pieces. Others argue that true originality is essential. Should we value speed and efficiency or prioritize authentic creative expression?
Constructive Debater 1 Loren Using AI to create artwork is appealing, especially for teen artists like me who want fast results. It helps us stay relevant and share fresh pieces quickly. In contests or school projects, speeding up production can be a game-changer. Even if some styles feel familiar, starting work with AI tools gives us time to refine ideas. In today’s fast-moving digital world, people expect new content constantly. Waiting too long can mean missing the chance to stand out or inspire others.
Constructive Debater 2 Olivia It’s wiser to prioritize authentic creativity over relying on AI-generated art. For teens like me, creating original work builds confidence and skill, while AI can blur authorship. Once posted online, AI art spreads quickly, making it hard to correct misconceptions. People may assume the work is entirely original, even if it’s not. Putting extra effort into personal ideas avoids confusion and fosters real innovation. Thoughtful design earns respect and showcases growth. In the long run, genuine art holds more value than quick results.
Rebuttal Debater 1 Loren AI-generated art may resemble existing work, but refusing to use AI tools can hold teens like us back. With AI, we can explore different ideas quickly and meet tight deadlines. As we increase our understanding of AI and grow more skilled at using it, we may be able to create art that humans alone cannot produce. Consistently producing eye-catching work can also build confidence and momentum. Holding back out of fear of inadvertently copying existing work might limit our creative development.
Rebuttal Debater 2 Olivia While generating art quickly can be helpful, duplicated designs can cause real issues. Teens may rely on AI without learning key techniques, limiting long-term growth. Adjusting some parts of an AI-generated artwork to add freshness to it wouldn’t help much. If people see recycled elements, they may question the work’s originality. Taking time to refine personal ideas is more responsible. Thoughtful creation protects authenticity, builds a stronger artistic reputation, and helps avoid flooding social media with repetitive content.
Judge’s Comments AI can boost productivity, but relying on it risks repetition and stunted artistic growth. Genuine creativity builds trust and originality. What’s your take on using AI in art?
May For The Junior Times junior/1745287514/1613368104
1. According to Construcive Debater 1 Loren, what advantage does starting with AI tools provide artists?
2. Accordng to Constructive Debater 2 Olivia, why might original work earn more respect than AI-generated work?
3. According to Rebuttal Debater 2 Loren, why might refusing to use AI tools hold teens back?
4. According to Rebuttal Debater 2 Olivia, what advantage does building a strong artistic reputation offer?
1. Have you ever used AI tools for a school project or contest?
2. What are ways to ensure art remains personal and authentic in a digital world?
3. Should speed and meeting deadlines be a major reason to use AI?
4. Is there a right way to mix AI tools and personal creativity without losing originality?
Introduction>>
Rebuttal Debater 1 Loren 
